Jane Steele by Lyndsay Faye

Sometimes it’s the books we love the most that are the hardest to write about, right?  I loved Lyndsay Faye’s Jane Steele, plain and simple.  It’s a novel that I want to buy so that I can read it again.  I can see it becoming a “comfort read” for me in the future.  It’s genuinely romantic, a page-turning mystery, and a surprisingly feminist spin on a classic, Charlotte Bronte’s Jane Eyre.

I have only read Jane Eyre once  – I know, GASP! – back in high school.  It’s one of those books that I’ve been meaning to reread for ages.  But it’s influence is so widespread that the story feels fresh to me somehow.  I certainly don’t think you have to have read Jane Eyre recently or ever to enjoy Jane Steele, but for me it added an extra layer of enjoyment.

IMG_3493This is not what I would call a retelling, but rather I feel it is a companion piece to the original.  This Jane tells us from the first page,

I have been reading over and over again the most riveting book titled Jane Eyre, and the work inspires me to imitative acts.  My new printing features a daring introduction by the author railing against the first edition’s critics.  I relate to this story almost as I would a friend or a lover – at times I want to breathe it’s entire alphabet into my lungs, and at others I should prefer to throw it across the room.  Whoever heard of disembodied voices calling to governesses, of all people, as this Jane’s do?

Jane Steele is also an orphan, suffers at a horrible boarding school, and she becomes a governess, but there is one huge difference from the original – she’s a murderer.  This is not a spoiler, as it’s on the inside jacket flap and included in the first sentence.  I will say that she does not kill for fun.  Jane Steele is a warrior, fiercely protective of the people she cares for.  Perhaps this is what I loved most about the novel – her spirit of resourcefulness and capability, and her courage.  There is a decidedly feminist tone to the book, in Jane’s strength and also in her ownership of her sexuality.  Jane is a realistically lusty woman, and I appreciated that.

Which brings me to the romance at the heart of the novel.  I am not a dedicated romance reader, as a genre, but I DO appreciate a heartfelt, moving, deeply felt love story.  Lyndsay Faye has succeeded in bringing to life a sexy, slightly tortured, romantic pairing in Jane and Mr. Thornfield. I will not say more because I don’t want to spoil the plot.  But I loved, loved, loved, the pacing and unfolding of Jane’s attraction to her pupil’s father figure.

There’s also a riveting mystery about something precious hidden in a trunk, and a whole bunch of history about the British and Sikh wars in the Punjab, and all the while Jane is terrified of her past catching up with her.  I simultaneously couldn’t turn pages fast enough and didn’t want it to end.

I’m thrilled to have discovered that Lyndsay Faye has written previous novels and am adding them all to my TBR.  And I bought a used copy of Jane Eyre at the bookstore tonight.  I’m inspired now to reread the original after all this time.   This is going up there with Cynthia D’Aprix Sweeney’s The Nest for my favorite books of the year so far.  It’s also my first read for the 10 Books of Summer challenge.  What a fun, well-written book to kick off my challenge!




20 thoughts on “Jane Steele by Lyndsay Faye

  1. Ooh, so glad to hear you loved it! Can’t wait now! I read Jane Eyre so often in my teens and twenties that I know it backwards even though it’s probably at least twenty years since I last opened it. I’m glad it’s not a retelling – I find they hardly ever work. But it’s fun when someone does a good spin-off from one of the classics. I read Faye’s first book The Gods of Gotham when it came out, and while it didn’t quite blow me away, I thought it was a good debut and showed a lot of potential.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. This sounds so good! I’ve seen this here and there, but hadn’t gotten such a great synopsis yet. And it’s been too long since I’ve read Jane Eyre as well… I think it might be time to dig back into it!!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. The stuff about Sikhs in the Punjab is what has most drawn me to this book. I’m a huge huge HUGE fan of the original Jane Eyre (read it when I was eight and so many rereads since then), so I’m not typically interested in retellings of it. But yeah, the Sikh history stuff sounds super great. (So does the murdering, tbh.)


    1. Jenny, I think you will like this. Normally I’m not much for retellings. But Faye’s obvious love of the original source material shines through, and her spin on it is so well-written. I found it very satisfying. (Then again, I’ve only read Jane Eyre once!)


  4. I was wondering how I missed this! I was waiting for your review because this is one I’m wanting to read this summer, then realized all of my subscriptions on wordpress disappeared from my reader, but not the ones outside of wordpress? Not sure how that happened. Anyway, glad I came over and checked you out. I want to reread Jane Eyre and read this too! I’m so glad it was well done.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. AHHHHH! Jane Eyre is my all-time favorite classic and one of my favorite books of all time. The writing, the atmosphere, the plot, the characters: GENIUS. I would recommend reading it again! I hope I get to read this…and hopefully won’t be let down 🙂
    Kate @Read and Dream

    Liked by 1 person

  6. So completely agree with your sentiment about finding it hard to review some of our favorite books; I felt that way this year about “The Last Painting of Sara de Vos” – it left me so speechless I *still* haven’t written a review of it although I read it months ago. I’m so glad to hear you feel this way about Jane Steele – I bought it but still haven’t read it so this is motivation to dig it out. Wonderful review as always 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s