The Bird’s Nest by Shirley Jackson (20 Books of Summer #16/Classics Club #7)

The Bird’s Nest is the Shirley Jackson’s third novel, published in 1954, and it is just as quirky and oddball as you might expect if you’ve ever read her before. It’s the fifth one I’ve read by her so far and it is my least favorite, but still it is more thought-provoking and entertaining than many novels published today. Jackson has a way of describing human relationships and the human mind that is deliciously off-kilter and insightful. In this tale of a young woman’s deepening mental illness Jackson explores what it means to download (1)be human and how trauma can affect the mind.

Elizabeth Richmond had a corner of an office on the third floor; it was the section of the museum closest , as it were, to the surface, that section where correspondence with the large world outside was carried on freely, where least shelter was offered to cringing scholarly souls. At Elizabeth’s desk on the highest floor of the building, in the most western corner of the office, she sat daily answering letters offering the museum collections of pressed flowers, or old sea-chests brought back from Cathay. It is not proven that Elizabeth’s person equilibrium was set off balance by the slant of the office floor, nor could it be proven that if was Elizabeth who pushed the building off its foundations, but it is undeniable that the began to slip at about the same time.

Living with her aunt Morgen and working in a hum-drum job at a museum, Elizabeth starts experiencing perplexing and frightening symptoms, like losing gaps of time and horrendous headaches and backaches. She also starts receiving threatening notes at the museum. Her aunt takes her to a doctor, who recommends a psychiatrist, Dr. Wright. Dr. Wright suggests hypnosis to try and get at the root of the problem, as “Miss R” (the doctor’s initial name for Elizabeth) insists there’s nothing wrong with her. When he puts her under hypnosis for the first time, Dr. Wright sees something that leaves him shaken:

…I wonder, though, how I ever thought her handsome. Because she was not, I saw, at all handsome, and as I watched her in horror, the smile upon her soft lips coarsened, and became sensual and gross, her eyelids fluttered in an attempt to open, her hands twisted together violently, and she laughed, evilly and roughly, throwing her head back and shouting, and I, seeing a devil’s mask where a moment before I had seen Miss R.’s soft face, thought only, it cannot be Miss R.; this is not she.

Little by little the hypnosis starts revealing that Elizabeth’s personality has split into four distinct personas: Elizabeth, Betsy, Beth, and Bess. There is a hinted trauma in Elizabeth’s past involving her mother, which Dr. Wright thinks is perhaps the origin of her mental illness. One section of the book is narrated by Betsy, who is the most lively and interesting personality. She takes off for New York City trying to find her mother. This was one of my favorite parts of the book because I had no clue where the story was going, and Betsy experiencing total freedom and control of the other personalities was entertaining, like a naive child out in the world for the first time.

I won’t spoil any more of the plot but I’ll just mention that Dr. Wright himself occupies a large share of the book, and he’s really not the most interesting character. He likes to hear himself talk and Jackson gives him too much of the book’s real estate. He’s not malevolent but instead self-important and irritating. Betsy aptly calls him “Dr. Wrong.”

If you’ve never read Jackson before I wouldn’t start with this one. It could use a bit of editing and Jackson honed her craft as she wrote more, becoming better at characterization and narrative drive. However, if you are already a Jackson fan and want to read everything she’s written, you will probably enjoy this, if for nothing else than to see the ways in which her skills developed over time. It is a strange exploration of identity and I liked it.

Elizabeth spoke very slowly, feeling her way. “What he’s going to have when he’s through is a new Elizabeth Richmond, with her mind. She will think and eat and hear and walk and take baths. Not me. I’ll maybe be a part of her, but I won’t know it – she will.”

“I don’t get it,” said Morgen.

“Well,” said Elizabeth, “when she does all the thinking and knowing, won’t I be… dead?”

“Oh, now, look,” said Morgen, and then sat helplessly, facing the definition of annihilation.

(This is the 16th book from my 20 Books of Summer list and the 7th book from my Classics Club list. I know that today – Labor Day in the U.S. – marks the official end to 20 Books of Summer, but I have one more review to post. Expect my thoughts on George Saunders’s short story collection CivilWarLand in Decline sometime later this week.)

30 thoughts on “The Bird’s Nest by Shirley Jackson (20 Books of Summer #16/Classics Club #7)

  1. Great review! I really must read more Shirley Jackson some day – I’ve only read the three best known, We Have Always Lived…, The Haunting of Hill House and The Lottery. Not sure how much this one appeals – Dr Wrong might drive one or more of my personalities to murder… 😉

    Liked by 1 person

  2. “A strange exploration of identity” sounds so interesting, but I get what you mean about a writer developing their craft and the beginnings of it being evident in a book instead of something more honed and polished. This sounds like it’s worth picking up at some point though. Great review!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. so I just went to my library’s online site to request this and they don’t have it. So I searched on Shirley Jackson and NOPE?!?! They don’t have her listed? so weird!


  3. Oh this sounds good-I’ve never read Shirley Jackson (or heard of her) but I think I’d like her writing. I wonder if she included such a big section on the doctor because it was a male character? Back then, I can imagine publishers ‘coaching’ female writers to include more men in their books, just because of the time period, ya know?

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Yeeeeeeah, this isn’t my favorite of Shirley Jackson’s books. I didn’t love Hangsaman either, and I haven’t read Road through the Wall yet but I have….like, maybe not the highest hopes for it. The Sun-Dial is easily my favorite of Shirley Jackson’s lesser novels.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Elizabeth is the perfect character name for this premise; I wonder if her heroine began as a Lucy/Lucille and progressed to a Catherine/Cathy/Kat and then things went really bananas. I’m up for this one, in time, as I share your admiration of her, but will keep your reservations in mind.

    Liked by 1 person

  6. Great review, Laila! You did a wonderful job providing an alluring and atmospheric introduction to The Birds Nest. While I haven’t read any of Jackson’s writing (yet! Planned for October), I agree that this doesn’t seem like the right place to start. That said, I’m still intrigued. Multiple personality disorder is not something which appears in fiction often.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to booksbythecup Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s